John Hastie Museum – Strathaven – council closure announced
Sounding more like a traditional Glasgow City Council story – maybe South Lanarkshire Council has been looking around for inspiration – supporter’s are claiming that the council has no legal tight to close the John Hastie Museum because the building and land it stands on were a gift to the town, and have cited the terms of John Hasties’ bequest, within which the museum and park were given for “the free use, enjoyment and recreation, and to deposit his guns and all gear within a hall or house for the use and recreation of the inhabitants in the town of Strathaven.”
The council has approved the closure of the museum, which was opened in 1915, to make an annual saving of £20,000.
However, it has also given local groups and organisation a month to present alternative proposal for the building, issuing a statement:
“Although South Lanarkshire Council has approved the permanent closure of John Hastie Museum, it has been agreed that local organisations and groups are given time to produce proposals for alternative uses of the building.”
The council has said it doesn’t know how much it costs to run the museum, but that it knows it can make the £20,000 saving each year by closing it.
It also declined to provide a spokesperson to speak to STV, or allow the reporter to access the closed museum, and film inside.
The matter has been taken up by MSP Aileen Campbell, who just arrived in the post after winning the recent election. Speaking to STV News, the MSP said:
“There’s been no discussion or involvement with the community, so obviously I want to help the group who are concerned about this and help reverse this decision in some way, or at least have the council re-examine it.”
A local campaigner, Bob Currie, said:
“They’ve trodden over the people of Strathaven with their actions. It would be a loss culturally, historically, socially, educationally.”
MSP calls for rethink on Strathaven museum closure | Glasgow and West | STV News
Archeolink vistor attraction set to close in 2011
I have to confess to passing the Archaeolink Prehistory Park, an Aberdeenshire family attraction where visitors were invited to Travel 10,000 years in one day from the Mesolithic to a Roman Marching Camp. Apart from not being mad keen – but still interested – in such far back history, time was the real problem, as I was always en route to places further north.
The centre is now closed, and looks likely to stay that way unless financial backers are found to subsidise the attraction:
BBC News – Aberdeenshire tourist attraction Archaeolink to close
Archaeolink trustees in last-ditch attempt to reopen prehistory park – Press & Journal
Last-ditch bid to save Archaeolink – Evening Express
Sadly, I always find myself stuck between the proverbial Rock and a Hard Place when I read these stories. On the one hand, I believe we need to have such facilities in order to make the subjects they cover interesting, and to provide employment and education. On the other, I can’t see how they can justify their existence if they are not viable, and pay for themselves by bringing sufficient numbers through their doors.
Archeolink opened in 1997 (in a ceremony with Time Team’s Tony Robinson centre stage), and has been receiving a subsidy of £135,000 per annum from Aberdeenshire Council (for the past five years), and according to the media reports posted a loss of £130,000 for the period 2009-10, accompanied by falling visitor numbers, with 10,500 being reported for the same period – no indication was given of earlier numbers. However, it did state that each visitor was subsidised to the extent of £13 by the council, and a single adult ticket cost £6.10.
It seems it did not go down too well with the locals though, who branded it a “white elephant” from the start, and it failed to attract the expected numbers of visitors.
I’m not surprised, reading on, we learn that Audit Scotland once warned the local authority that it would have to repay a £2 million grant which had been received from the European Regional Development Fund if the trust which then ran the place was disbanded before June 2007. At the time, Press and Journal was told that the council “couldn’t afford to close it down”.
I suspect the problem is that it was built too far away from a suitable pool of visitors, and once everyone who could visit it had seen it a few times, they got bored, and people from further away would only make the trip once, so that stream of repeat business was never a reality. In all likelihood, potential visitor numbers were ‘massaged’ at an early stage, in order to endure the grant referred to earlier was won. Fine if the feet fall through the door, but in the harsh reality of daylight, no amount of visitor number projections will materialise if the distances are too far, and entrance charges too high – even if fair and subsidised. It’s all very well talking something up, but if it fails to deliver, it will ultimately fail as no-one will pour money into a bottomless hole forever. According to the local authority, it has assets worth £1.7 million as of 2010.
A petition was raised to appeal for support to keep the attraction open:
Save Archaeolink Petition, Aberdeenshire Scotland
Update
On April 1, 2011, there was news that the feature could be saved, as the trust which runs it said it would find the money to pay staff from its own funds, and that there was an as yet unnamed party interested in the park.
BBC News – Archaeolink Prehistory Park could be saved
Update
No joy for this park, as it is to finally be wound up.
Archaeolink Prehistory Park in Oyne opened in 1997 but was closed in March.
Negotiations to keep it open have failed to secure its future, and the trust which runs the project said this means the property will be officially handed back to Aberdeenshire Council
BBC News – Oyne’s Archaeolink Prehistory Park to be wound up
World-class startup lab at Dundee University closes
Having been in the position to go ‘cap in hand’ to bodies such as Scottish Enterprise in an effort to raise fairly modest sum of money to start or maintain small businesses, I’ve always looked in amazement at the way some startups can conjure up multi-million pound finance packages for what look – to me at least – some fairly speculative and risky ventures, often with promised of future returns that would probably have the Dragons falling off their chairs with laughter.
While I’ve never been involved in developing things such as drugs or treatments, I do appreciate the costs involved, so it’s no surprise to learn that the Translational Medicine Research Collaboration (TMRC) needed an £11.6 million research facility, or that it was founded in 2006 with a Scottish Enterprise grant of £17.5 million.
Opened less than two years ago, by Scotland’s First Minister, the multi-million pound medical laboratory will be shut down my March 31, 2011, after which the building will be used by the university’s school of medicine.
The collaboration was a partnership between the universities of Dundee, Aberdeen, Edinburgh and Glasgow, their corresponding health boards, Scottish Enterprise and global pharmaceutical company Wyeth. In a statement, TMRC said, ‘The TMRC partners are currently reviewing and evaluating the structure of this collaboration to develop a more sustainable model of operation.’
However, given the hoops I (or rather we) were forced to turn somersaults through for what amounted to only a few thousand pounds, I’m more than a little dismayed to see that this supposedly ‘world-class’ facility, which Scottish Enterprise said at the time would create 50 jobs at the ‘state-of-the-art’ lab, “rising to as many as 120 over five years”.
I can’t help but feel that someone should have seen that this was not really going to go anywhere realistic way back at the start, when the open hands were being held out.
A University of Dundee spokesman said 28 university employees were currently working at the research lab, 11 had been redeployed to other areas of the university, eleven have moved on to alternative employment, another had retired, and that nine staff were left, with the university trying to redeploy them and avoid compulsory redundancies.
BBC NEWS | Scotland | Tayside and Central | Disease research gets £8m funding January 2007
BBC NEWS | Scotland | Tayside and Central | £11.6m drug research lab opened April 2009
Clydebuit Museum will close on October 16 2010

Clydebuilt Museum
The closure of the Clydebuilt Museum at Braehead has been announced due to lack of funding.
I had no idea this closure was on the cards, and find the news rather depressing – we seem to mention only museum closures, not openings.
In many ways though, I am not completely surprised. Having been there a few times over the years, it was like visiting a ghost ship, and despite fairly well assembled displays and interactive goodies to play with, I was usually there alone, or with only a handful of other patrons.
I suspect lack of interest rather than lack of funding is the true story (as my visits to the Scottish Maritime Museum at Irvine have been similarly lonely, and I thought the place was shut the first time I visited), which is a bit of a shame, since Clydebuilt is right beside the packed Braehead Shopping Centre – full of potential patrons, but it looks as if they are more interested in shopping than history.
From its own web site:
Please be aware that Clydebuilt will be closing it’s (sic) doors for good in October, our last day will Saturday 16th. We would like to thank all our visitors over the 11 years we have been open. If you wish to join the Facebook campaign to try and save the museum, type in ‘Save Clydebuilt’ into the search bar on Facebook.
Scottish Maritime Museum – Braehead
Specially built to house the exhibits it contains, and with various plans for waterbuses and other floating attraction during its life, these have never come to pass despite various promises.
Again, we just do not seem to be able to put ‘bums on seats’ any more – and it makes a mockery of the Scottish Government’s call for a massive increase in tourism over the next few years.
Other than the scenery, there will soon be nothing for tourists to come and see or visit – except the shops.
Ah, perhaps that’s the real master plan – a tourist separated from their money is worth more than one spending a £1 or four for admission (or even nothing for our free entry museums) and hours staring at exhibits.
(Yes, I know, I’m just an old cynic
)
Bute cheese set to become extinct
It was disappointing to see the news that the Rothesay Creamery is to cease production – meaning that at least 19 jobs will be lost on the Isle of Bute.
Operator First Milk announced plans to close the facility in light of a significant fall in the production of milk on the island. It seems that this has fallen by more than 25% over the past two years, with the result that the creamery is under-utilised, and losing money as a result. From the outside, it has seemed that there were problems, but that things were able to continue, but it would seem that the situation is no longer sustainable, and First Milk is having to consider its responsibilities in Campbeltown and Arran, where it also has creameries. The company has said it will continue to collect milk produced on Bute, and transport it to the mainland. There are currently 14 dairy farms on the island.
There will no doubt be the usual politicised views, posturing, blame and accusations to follow from various sources, and a 30-day consultation period on the proposal is set to begin next week.
Isle of Bute Cheddar is described as a high value product, and a respected brand – I hope, I’m afraid I’m a fussy cheese eater, and don’t like cheddar – so there is always a chance that there may be someone out there with different resources and facilities on tap, which can be utilised in a way to make the product viable under the given circumstances, so there is always a chance that it may be rescued or revived
Read further details and follow developments in:
Rothesay creamery set to cease production – Buteman Today
Update March 25, 2010
The Buteman published a verbatim account of an interview where it posed several questions to First Milk’s communications director, Paul Flanagan:
First Milk: big questions, important answers – Buteman Today
Worth reading, as it tends to suggest someone has a vivid imagination, or is a stranger to the truth, as Paul Flanagan suggests that, “It is important that Alan and Robert carefully check the facts before they make allegations.
Robert is councillor Robert Macintyre, Argyll & Bute Council depute leader, council spokesman on the economy, environment and rural affairs, and Bute dairy farmer, while Alan is Alan Kennedy, Bute NFU branch chairman. Both accuse First Milk of “serious mismanagement”. Both clearly have an axe to grind with First Milk, and Paul Flanagan refuted their joint claim with performance figures quoted from recent years, showing that First Milk had far exceeded the sales performance of those companies previously managing the brand.
NFU Scotland president Jim McLaren, and colleagues George Jamieson and Lucy Sumsion, met the 14 remaining dairy farmers on Bute at the island’s Kingarth Hotel to discuss the implications of the closure announcement:
Farming bosses in Rothesay creamery talks – Buteman Today
Update April 01, 2010
It just might be that some sort of sense might be seen on Bute (of a type generally lacking on the mainland) and that a change in market trends may see a sensible response where all parties work towards a solution (which may, or may not ultimately be palatable or popular), rather than adopt unwavering “Them and Us” stances from the outset, which makes the chances of a positive outcome somewhat less than likely.
After the negative sign of the opening salvos (noted above), where both the local councillor and the NFU chairman could have provoked First Milk by accusing it of “serious mismanagement” in an apparently unjustified outburst, the news is of positive discussions, where meeting attended by First Milk, Argyll and Bute Council, NFU Scotland, HIE (Highlands and Islands Enterprise), the Bute Estate, local dairy farmers and the island’s MP Alan Reid, among others, with enterprise minister and Argyll and Bute MSP Jim Mather in the chair, ended with the news that First Milk would be prepared to sell the plant if the right deal was made.
A £15,000 feasibility study is to follow, carried out by HIE in conjunction with First Milk, tasked with examining various options for keeping the Bute creamery open.
Signs of hope after creamery talks? – Buteman Today
Update April 28, 2010
News of the decision to en production at the Rothesay Creamery on May 07, 2010, was carried by The Buteman online on April 28, 2010.
A spokesman for the creamery said the decision had been made following the continuing losses being made by the plant, and the lack of any offers to purchase the plant following the original closure announcement which had been made in mid-March.
Although a feasibility study into the marketing of milk from Bute, being carried out by the Scottish Agricultural College, was still to be completed as this closure confirmation was announced. The news report noted that some employees may be retained for a time after May 07, to mothball the plant, implying that if a workable plan resulted from the feasibility study, the plant could be restarted.
News of the closure makes depressing reading. Not because of the closure itself, but the response by local dairy farmer Alan Kennedy, who also chairs the Bute branch of the National Farmers’ Union.
Since the first announcement, his comments have been anything but constructive towards First Milk and its management, and even though he is described as a local dairy farmer, and must therefore be running a business and have books to balance, he expresses surprise that the loss-making plant has been closed as its losses increase, and has even accused the company of intending to close the creamery regardless, and of not wanting anyone else there.
If I was sitting across the negotiating table from Mr Kennedy, and that was his attitude, I would close my factory and cut my losses at the earliest opportunity.
One doesn’t have to ‘cap in hand’ to negotiations, but a certain amount of discretion might be a good idea until the outcome is confirmed.
BREAKING NEWS: Closure of Rothesay Creamery is confirmed – Buteman Today
Update January 2012
THE site of the former creamery at Townhead was purchased by local firm Bute Island Foods Ltd, from First Milk.
The company manufactures and exports Sheese, described as a dairy-free vegan alternative to cheese.
Bute firm buys Rothesay Creamery site – Local Businesses – The Buteman
Suspected arson destroys Denbigh’s Cae Dai 50s Museum
Note that since April 2010, the owner has been able to open a small display in the community hall on the Cae Dai site.
A suspected arson attack on the night of December 1, 2009, has completely destroyed Denbigh’s Cae Dai 50s Museum in North Wales, together with all but one of the exhibits, the lorry used in The Great Train Robbery of 1963 – an Austin Loadstar which had been fitted with a secret compartment to hide the proceeds. The lorry was used by the gang during the robbery, then later recovered during a police raid on the gang’s safe house, Leatherslade Farm in Oxfordshire.
Also lost were the Ford Anglia used in ITV’s Heartbeat, a car owned by Diana Dors, and Ford Fiesta once owned by Christine Keeler. Other vehicles lost included a Chrysler Windsor, Mercedes-Benz saloon (payment to the owner for a bad debt when he ran a garage in London) , Riley 1.5 saloon, A55 hearse, pink Vauxhall PA Cresta, Standard Pennant, Berkeley sports car, “big bumper” Cadillac convertible, and a BSA motorcycle. An FX3 taxi from the 1950s had also been recently acquired, to transport visitors to and from the local railway station. There were at least 12 cars in the museum at the time. Outside the main museum, were an A35 and an A40, plus a collection of Reliant three and four wheelers, two 195os shops, and a period garage. Also lost were Ronnie Biggs’ birth certificate, a mink coat in a glass case, and a collection of 1950′s boxing paraphernalia.
The museum was divided into a number of areas: Showbiz and Music, which featured a large collection of photographs, and a section on the owner’s own group of the 1950s, Sparrow and the Gossamers; Crime: the owner and his group had played at Esmereldas’s Bar, owned by the notorious Krays, who eventually employed him to run the bar, and featured various correspondence from them; Sports: the owner was an amateur boxer, with 200 contests to his name (and still runs the Denbigh Amateur Boxing Club – some 30 years after retiring from the ring); 1950s rooms: there were recreations of two lounges and two from the time, both fully furnished
The museum’s caretaker stayed in a caravan on the site, and was taken to hospital as a precaution measure in case he had suffered from smoke inhalation, but was released the following morning. The caravan he lived in while on the site was also destroyed by the fire.
The damage is estimated to be in the order of £100,000 with the building accounting for about £50,000 and insured, and the collection also at £50,000 but uninsured.
A 46-year old man was later arrested by police on suspicion of arson, and released on bail.
The Cae Dai 50s Museum web site is still online, together with its Guestbook where past visitors have been expressing their sadness at the loss.
The museum’s owner, Sparrow Harrison, has already indicated his intention to both restore and expand the museum, and offers of support and donations have already been reported.
Anyone able or wishing to help can get in touch with the 50s Museum through the web site given above, or by phone on 01745 817004 during office hours, or 01745 812107 at other times. The trust can also be emailed at: caedaitrust@tiscali.co.uk
I learned of this fire some time after the event, from one of my trade journals, but the incident was reported locally, The Leader – News from Wrexham & Flintshire – Suspected arson attack devastates Denbigh’s Cae Dai museum, and by BBC News – Arrest after 50s car museum blaze. The losses are unfortunate, and I have commented on the loss of many small museums throughout the country over the past decade, particularly in Scotland, not only to this sort of attrition, but to closure due to lack of interest or available finances or funding. I didn’t have the opportunity to visit Cae Dai, as it seems to have come into being just as my regular commutes to North Wales were coming to an end, so this is one I have definitely missed.
There may be later stories published on the web if more information comes to light, so it may be worth searching for the museum, to see if their is any conclusion to the story.
Cae Dai is more than just the museum mentioned above, and the following article which was published by The Independent in May, 1994, provides a more detailed description and background to the estate, and more current references can now be found on the web:
Cae Dai is Welsh for David’d Field. The Cae Dai Trust exists to help disadvantaged adults, and many of those who it assists also work within the Cae Dai programme. The trust was set up after the North Wales Psychiatric Hospital closed some time in the late 1980s.
Story update February 2010
I spotted an update to the above, in a letter published by Mr Sparrow thanking the various people and clubs that have come forward to offer help and support.
It seems that while the building were insured, the policy for the contents only came through the day after the fire. While the insurer is doing what it can, it seems that the fact that arson was definitely involved is complicating things a little. Because of this aspect, the owner is not touching anything, or starting any work until this issue is resolved. The local MP has offered his support too.
It’s just a shame that it’s so easy for some fool to ruin twenty year’s worth of someone’s work, and ruin things so completely for ordinary, decent folk.
I’m hoping there may be more details in the next month or so.
Good new – Update April 2010
I have to admit that I don’t look too closely at the news, as most of it’s depressing, so it’s a welcome change when something akin to good news is received.
In this case it’s the follow up to the Cae Dai story. As noted above, there was a problem with the insurance for the collection, as the documents were (I believe) one day out of date, therefore not in force. Following discussion and representations, the insurer has agreed to pay on both the building and the collection claims. The site is now reported to have been cleared, with only the remaining supporting structures present, although these have been condemned and will also be cleared before the restoration of the museum and collection proper begins.
It may have been the end of more than twenty years’ effort, but it looks as if the outcome will now be positive, and a ‘lost’ museum is on the road to recovery.
Temporary exhibition opens May 2010
Just at the end of April, I noted a news item telling of the opening of a temporary display in the community hall which lies on the Cae Dai site.
Owner Sparrow Harrison has noted that the number of visitors is similar to usual at this time of year, and that there is still plenty to see from the surving collection.
Admission is free, but donations are very welcome after the disaster at the museum.
Yorkshire Motor Museum closes
As if to emphasise my observation above that circumstances are changing, I also noted confirmation that the Yorkshire Motor Museum would close in 2010. Formerly known as the Skopos Motor Museum, located at Batley, West Yorkshire.
This was a more substantial affair than Cae Dai, and had around 70 vehicles on display, many belonging to the businessman Stephen Batte, who had created the museum. The remainder were on loan, meaning that the collection varied over time, making it more interesting. The museum had its own workshop, where restoration work could be carried out, and was a facility shared with the Northern Aeroplane workshop, which did work for the Shuttleworth Trust.
The museum was opened in 1996, by Lord Montague of Beaulieu, and covered everything from the earliest days of motoring through to the latest supercars. It seems that a change of landlord means the museum has to close by the end of January 2010, so it’s not only the tiny museums that can have survival problems.
Quoted from the museum’s own web site, which is still in existence as I type:
Yorkshire Motor Museum was founded by Stephen Battye in October 1993 as part of a regeneration scheme for Batley. it is the home of approx 40 classic and vintage cars. Some of which are owned by the museum and others are privately owned .
The museum workshop repairs and maintains the museum cars. Also, the museum takes in outside work for restoration repairs, and service.
It is also the home of the Northern Aeroplane Workshops (NAW) . The group is undertaking a “new-build” of a 1917 Sopwith Camel aircraft built to air worthy standards.
Glasgow loses Henry Healy chain
Although they were never particularly close to any of my haunts, or places of employment in Glasgow, anyone that spent any wandering the length and breadth of Glasgow city could hardly fail to notice that there was more than one branch of Henry Healy to be found.
Although I knew the chain was long established, I had never counted the shops, or even thought about their history, but history is now the operative word, with the news that the six shops that made up the group have closed, meaning the city has lost yet another long established family businesses, and one of the oldest that still remained, reported to have been founded in 1913. Liquidators Begbies Traynor said the chain had suffered a downturn in the face of competition from national chains together with the impact of the recession. 27 people have been made redundant as a result.
The chain had been run by Henry Healy, grandson of the founder of the grocery shops, although they are now being described as sandwich bars.
The shops were sited in Hope Street, Queen Street, Howard Street, Mitchell Street, Stockwell Street and Sauchiehall Street.
NTS announces cuts and cost savings
Having announced (on Thursday) that almost one fifth of its full time staff were to be lost in order to cut costs, and that seasonal staff would not be taken on in the usual way, the National Trust for Scotland (NTS) has given details of cost saving changes at 11 properties it manages. Changes will see buildings close at some properties while the surrounding gardens remain open.
Hill of Tarvit Mansion House, Fife, will close.
The David Livingstone Centre, Blantyre, will be returned to trustees if new funding cannot be found.
Leith Hall House, Aberdeenshire, will close however the gardens will remain open.
Barry Mill in Angus and Hugh Miller’s Cottage in Cromarty will seek external sponsorship.
Kellie Castle, Fife, will be operated by volunteers but will close to visitors if its current deficit cannot be resolved, however the grounds will remain open.
Garden properties at Arduaine in Argyll, Inveresk in Midlothian, and the Mountain Visitor Centre at Ben Lawers, Perthshire, will be closed.
(Arduaine might be interesting, as I remember reading of much disagreement between NTS and the former caretaker in the letters pages of the Scots Magazine some years ago. Like most disputes that take place in public through letters pages, there was no conclusion – for the time I was reading anyway, just two sides, each politely claiming the other was wrong and each pointing out politely that the other was misguided in their beliefs. Closing the gardens to public access could re-ignite things, if they were ever defused that is, as the NTS was supposed to have breached the terms by which they were given the gardens. Presumably continued public access would have been one of those terms, but I’m just guessing, so don’t quote me.)
Haddo House, Aberdeenshire, will operate only for functions, although the shop, tearooms and gardens will remain open.
Hutchesons’ Hall, Glasgow, will be let to a long-term tenant.
The NTS formerly employed almost 500 full-time staff and 800 seasonal employees.
















